We all seem to simultaneously love and loathe Facebook. I roll my eyes at loads of status updates, including my own, yet I post away. I see status updates wherein Facebookers reflect on how tiresome and narcissistic social media sites are. We love to hate it, and we hate to love it. It’s just so darn efficient! But it’s also like a virtual world, and by virtual, I kind of mean fake.
Facebook allows us to do our own PR, to some extent. We can create this online persona in just a few easy clicks. And for the most part, we want that persona to appear shining and beautiful and happy. We seek to put our most glamorous side first: the best pictures, the most witty, quippy status updates, the most relevant and hard-hitting interviews, the funniest Onion articles. I get it – it’s the same reason we all wear nice clothes out on the town, versus stained, schlumpy sweatpants and our old tennis camp sweatshirt. (Unless we live in Brooklyn, then indeed we might wear a look that says “just-pulled-from-hamper,” but in Brooklyn it’s ironic and hip and paired with the perfect aviator Raybans.) We want people to think highly of us; we want to be well-liked. It’s natural.
So how do you feel when you read Facebook? I get the appeal of the instant connection. You can check up on two dozen friends’ lives over one cup of coffee from your kitchen table. You can feel “in touch” so quickly. But I have to tell you, I sometimes read Facebook and get totally down. Why? Because nothing ever seems to be wrong with anyone on Facebook. Everyone just went for “a burning 10-mile run” or “kicked some ass at the gym with my trainer.” Or they are “going to the White House Correspondents’ Dinner…whatever shall I wear??” They “love, love, love the Hamptons” or they’re “JFK -> CDG -> MXP -> PRG”. They are “out at the Soho House/TenJune/Pink Elephant, models and bottles.” They’ve just made “the perfect beef bourguignon” or “a gorgeous port wine reduction sauce.” I’m exaggerating a bit here, but you get the picture. No one posts pictures of cellulite or double chins or embarrassing ketchup stains on Facebook. No one posts about “rockin a Quiznos sandwich.” No one burns dinner, or has their foundation garments hanging out of their clothes. My point is, if I let my mind drift this way, reading Facebook makes me feel like my life is so flawed. Have you ever heard that Simpsons line where Homer says “I’m so hungry I could eat at Arby’s!” My life seems so Arby’s so much of the time, but everyone else appears Le Cirque.
I’m reminded often of my friend Erica Carrig – an amazing woman – who in law school had a big interview with one New York law firm. When asked what she liked to do in her spare time she answered, “honestly? Weeeellll … pretty much … eat Doritos on my couch and watch Days of our Lives.” I loved that answer. (And apparently the law firm did too, because Erica is now about to make partner there.) People love honesty. It’s fresh. Invigorating. For me, it’s totally inspiring. It makes me feel better about myself and my foibles.
Last August, I decided to experiment with honesty and make a series of confessions on Facebook. I took one week, seven days, and posted one embarrassing, confessional status update each day. This was stuff I wasn’t crazy about people knowing. I just wanted to recalibrate, and to stop trying to be someone online who I am not offline. I wanted to stop annoying myself with…myself. You know, for the most part people seemed really refreshed by the honesty. But then at the end of the seven days, I overheard a friend say to someone else “did you see those confessions, are you kidding me? Why didn’t she confess about [this one totally horrible thing I did while in my first marriage.] ” I couldn’t’ reply or defend myself because I wasn’t meant to overhear. But this was so incredibly gutting. So totally deflating. You can’t even put confessions out there without people digging through them qualitatively and saying “Please go ahead and confess the very worst – don’t waste our time with this middling stuff.”
I wish we’d all feel secure enough in ourselves to be able to post the good, the bad and the ugly. But I’m one to talk – I’m not that secure. Modesty aside, it’s very unlikely that I’ll post a picture of myself in a bathing suit, or even standing in unflattering light. I might post the vaguely embarrassing things I do, but not the ones that make me really cringe. I won’t wax poetic about my weight gain, or how I tore a $200 pair of J.Brand jeans by aspiring to wear one size too small. But then again maybe I’ll try to… and I sure would love if other folks would too. Wouldn’t that make Facebook that much more fun?
Chat soon,
Liz
p.s. per paragraph 2, the funniest Onion article I’ve read is this: http://www.theonion.com/articles/hey-you-got-something-to-eat,11163/ Just doesn’t get old.